Looks like we’re just about ready to deal with Emilio Barbarigo. At least, we will be once we finish a few more preparation tasks.

As a history fun fact, apparently Cantarella was a poison that the Borgias allegedly made frequent use of during Rodrigo Borgia’s term as pope, though it is more of a myth than something substantiated by historical record. Still, for a work of fiction its a useful tool for a writing team to employ to add some authenticity to their storyline.

Aside from that, though it might be easy to clown on a late 2000s tailing mission, I admit that it’s easy to feel like a badass stalking our targets in the streets. When using the factions like courtesans and thieves to run interference with the guards, we begin to embody the Ezio from the E3 trailer, where we’re using our contacts to set up the moment we can strike in the middle of the crowd (despite not actually assassinating anyone during these tailing missions).

It’s as much a core part of the fantasy that Assassin’s Creed 2 is invoking as the actual moment where our Hidden Blade gets embedding into the target’s throat.

It didn’t take us long to identify our next target in scenic Venezia, and acquire allies in our fight against him. The merchant king has bought himself time, but not much of it.

Looking over a Let’s Play of the original version, the issue I have with the eyes on Rosa’s model is still there, but much harder to see then it was here in this re-released version. We can only partially blame the up-res here.

Having said that, one of the things that this episode demonstrates, and a key contributor to why Ezio became so popular, is that even as a revenge-seeking adult, he retains the charisma and charm of his younger self. His banter with Rosa, like Catarina back in Forli, feels natural.

And given the time period this was developed in, it would have been easy to write this in a chauvinistic manner, but at least from my viewpoint the writing team does an excellent job at avoiding that trap. He’s more than happy to learn from anyone who can do something better than he can, like Paolo back in Florence or Rosa in Venice. It’s not perfect, but it’s a lot better than I’d expect from games written in the late 2000s.

It makes him a very easy character to like, despite the job description.

Looks like Desmond’s visions are lasting for longer than 30 seconds. If this was a professional outfit, he might want to see a doctor about that.

But I guess we’ll just have to make it work.

I must admit, I like the scene where Altair does a leap of faith and the camera doesn’t follow him. It’s a good way to use the conceit of the game’s narrative to show how his relationship with Maria has become something more (in the PSP game).

That said, it’s definitely a shame that our time in Venice begins with one of the worst mission types from this era, escorting an NPC who has many 3 lines total that repeat endlessly on loop. We are lucky that this mission is easy, otherwise it could be far more grating on the nerves.

Oh well. At least we’re now in contact with the Thieves’ Guild. Maybe next time they’ll show us that cool move from before.

Turns out the Leonardo Da’Vinci also just happens to be on his way to beautiful Venice. Perhaps he’ll be willing to travel with us since we’ve become such good friends.

I somehow managed to forget that there’s a mission where do a classic video game “protect the carriage” mission, except our cargo is Leonardo Da’Vinci on his way to Venice. Honestly, the goofiness of the whole affair is part of what makes it so fun. If one aims to fictionalize historical events in a video game, they might as well take full advantage of the setting.

What I can fault them for is how little time we actually spend in Forli as part of the main story. It seems strange to have this full map available to us, but only have it serve as a detour en route to our primary destination. Of course, there is a reason for it that we’ll get to later, but not one that I find satisfactory.

At the very least, in the downtime we get to spend some more time with Desmond and the “real-world” portion of the fiction for a brief moment. Like I said before, Desmond was not a very well-received character critically, but he had already been baked into the franchise as a linchpin that binds together all of the ancestors we would play as, as was The Animus as a vehicle to execute on that premise. Thus, the dev team did their best to only use him sparingly enough to advance the main thread while allocating as much time as possible to Ezio and his journey.

Though we won’t get to them, it became clear later on that many of the games released after his story-line was revolved suffered for it. His character did a lot of heavy-lifting tying all of the various threads of the franchise together, and without someone like him in that role it became difficult to maintain a sense of forward momentum.

The lesson to learn from this is simple: Never listen to your fans. They don’t know what they want.

With our little detour complete, it’s time to eliminate the remaining leader of the Pazzi Conspiracy: Jacopo de’Pazzi.

And nothing puts one in the place of late-2000s era game design like an old-fashioned tailing mission. At least this one has the mercy to be brief and easy.

And this revolves all of our lingering business in Florence (aside from The Truth, which we will get to later). With that out of the way, let us begin our journey to Venice.

Though the Pazzi Conspiracy has been thwarted, those responsible for it have yet to be put to the sword. Or, as is the case, a hidden blade.

But first, perhaps a quick detour to some of the game’s side content.

This episode marks the first in which we unlock a fragment of “The Truth”. The puzzles have to do with the meta-fictional layer of global conspiracy theory that surrounds the basic premises of the franchise.

At the time, this was a hook that drew a lot of players into the franchise, studying these puzzles and what they might imply for the fictionalized history of Assassin’s Creed. I remember personally spending a ton of time of forums and other fan sites digging into the lore as presented, and I know I wasn’t alone in that.

But that was back in 2009, and this is 2024. While I’m still nostalgically fond of “The Truth”, even I must admit that it hits different now than it did back in the day. It puts into the mind of the ill-fated X-Files reboot back in 2016 actually. As a show, The X-Files revels in the sort of conspiratorial thinking that was often seen a fun joke or fringe area of interest back in the 90s and 2000s. There was a sense of “innocent fun” in cooking up these insane global conspiracies.

Now though, these type of fiction hits much differently. As the X-Files found out the hard way with that 6-episode run, global conspiracy fiction doesn’t have the same appeal in an area where congresspeople genuinely believe in things like QAnon, and the “innocent fun” now represents severe real world ramifications. I don’t necessarily fault the game for that, or the dev team, because it wouldn’t be possible for them to know how poorly it would age, but there’s no denying that in this context it does age poorly.

I still haven’t fully unpacked how the discrepancy between my nostalgia for it all contrasts and clashes with the tastelessness I know associate with it, but we still have time to dissect that as our playthrough continues.

While the real life members of the Pazzi Conspiracy were publicly executed, we’re playing as an Assassin. It’s only natural that the game fudges history to let us deliver justice.

I was looking for the exact moment where Roger Craig Smith switched from doing young Ezio’s voice to older Ezio’s voice, and I appear to have missed it. I can tell watching through this footage that he’s already begun to use the older Ezio’s voice in his performance. Credit to him because the transition is so natural that it slipped by me even as I was actively looking for it.

The other item worth pointing out is that while it wouldn’t be impossible to pull off a sequence like this in the original Assassin’s Creed’s structure, it would be difficult to do convincingly. As much as I would personally prefer that structure, this more linear, narrative-focused and mission-driven template allows the design team more flexibility with crafting the overall experience in exchange for reducing the degree of player freedom with each assassination mission.

Admittedly, I find it difficult to reconcile my desire to have more open-ended assassination missions, and investigations into each target, with the cold reality that with part of why Ezio is such a beloved character is because he goes through a strongly-defined arc over the course of the game. Said arc is made as powerful and affecting as it is precisely because Ubisoft’s development team can more rigidly define the order of events in a way they could not with Altair in the first game.

I think, even if it left me personally out in the cold, I respect the decisions that were ultimately made to move to this updated style. At the very least, it was obvious that Ubisoft still had immense respect for their original formula and tried to incorporate as much of it as they could while updating and iterating on it.

It’s become clear that we aren’t the only assassins working in Florence. Who better to stop assassins than a better Assassin?

As I’ve alluded to before, this whole section is based off a real life historical event where the Pazzi family and a number of other conspirators, with aid from the pope, attempted to assassinate the heads of the Medici family, who was the reigning political power in Florence. Given the veracity of those facts, it’s not too hard to imagine that, in the context of the game’s fictional conspiracy, the Templars would have been involved. Nor would it be too hard to envision that the Assassins would, in turn, stand against them.

Again, it’s an inspired choice that feels natural when laid out, seamlessly stitching together reality and fantasy into something that could be plausibly integrated into the tapestry of historical-fiction that the series has become since known for. I remember being so interested in the Italian Renaissance after playing through the Ezio trilogy that I used it as the basis for one of my projects in my World History class in college. It’s not a subject commonly taught in American schools, so much of it I had to look into on my own.

In hindsight, it’s pretty cool that a video game is what convinced me to do that.

Looks like we aren’t yet finished with the Pazzi family. They’re planning something, and we need to know whatever it is.

I am still kicking myself for doing all of the that talking without realizing that my mic was off and not recording even a second of it. Thankfully, I remember exactly what I was discussing, so I can just add it here.

Though I can no longer find it, I remember an interview where one of the creatives spokes about why Assassin’s Creed moved to the Italian Renaissance for the second game. They gave a few interesting reasons for it, that I wished to bring up.

The first was that, from the standpoint of level and world designers, the game’s setting needed to accommodate a protagonist capable of freerunning. This means that not only should it have tall buildings, but also buildings with a distinct visual style that make them pleasant to the eye and interesting traversal puzzles and obstacles. And of the times and places, late 15th century Italy had an abundance of both to take full advantage.

But more than that, this position in space-time occupies a unique historical context. We possess enough primary and secondary sources of information on the Italian Renaissance to have a strong idea of what it might have been like to live in there. We know of the power players and how they maneuvered themselves in the stage of political theater. However, there’s enough left undocumented, and we’re far enough removed from that time, that it is possible to take creative liberties with the source material that may or may not be true, but would be congruous with what we already know. Given that the conceit of the franchise is a world-spanning conspiracy theory that has been controlling society for much of world history, that’s fertile ground for a writing team.

And though the choice felt bold and refreshing at the time, and it was, those facts almost make it sound like a no-brainer. To the point where it feels strange that this setting was, and is still, so rarely tapped in video games.

With the death of one failson banker under our belt, our work as an Assassin has truly begun. But before we can take on our next target, we need to grow acclimated to our new life.

Technically, the “standard Ubisoft open world formula” started with the original Assassin’s Creed game, since that one had hundreds of flags scattered across the map to collect as a side activity. However, that was entirely superfluous and easy to ignore. And for that reason, most people didn’t bother.

I would posit that it truly got off the ground with this game, and its direct sequels which would use the same structure. As you can see, Assassin’s Creed 2 is much more overt about presenting its optional and collectible content to players in the story missions, and tying them into the overall narrative. Everything we do has some connection, either to Ezio or to Desmond.

• The Codex Pages were part of Ezio’s family legacy, and collecting them means resolving his father’s unfinished business.
• Naturally, as the landlord of Monterggioni, we want to improve and restore the place for both ourselves and the tenants.
• The Assassin Seals are again tied to Ezio’s family legacy, and that of the Assassin Order he’s now part of.
• The Eagle Feathers are a memento of the younger brother he lost, and a gift to his mother in the hopes that she’ll recover.
• And while the last collectible (which we haven’t done one of yet) isn’t important to Ezio, it is important to Desmond and the Scooby Gang.

This was the secret sauce that tied the whole room together: Making the side content part of the story, and giving the player tangible rewards in turn for engaging with it. I wonder also posit that much of this content (which the exception of the Eagle Feathers) was also executed far better here than it would be in later Ubisoft games (even beyond Assassin’s Creed), when the formula began to grow stale and stagnant.